Menu
Questions? Contact us at: 1-800-998-7750
FREE SHIPPING! on all items LEARN MORE

Breathable Underwear Comparison Chart

Click on the header of each column to sort in ascending or descending order.

Breathable Underwear JHM Rating Cost/Each** Description
Depend Underwear for Women Good $1.07
  • Elastic only on lower half of leg openings
  • No leakage barrier
  • Cardboard-like consistency
  • Least absorbent
Depend Underwear for Men Good $1.25
  • Elastic only on lower half of leg openings
  • No leakage barrier
  • Cardboard-like consistency
  • Least absorbent
Depend Adjustable Underwear 16oz Good $1.25
  • Pull on but tabs may be adjusted for snug fit
Tranquility Daytime 25 oz Best $1.25
  • Double leg cuffs
  • Inner peach mat disperses fluid
Tranquility Overnight 34oz Best $1.25
  • Exactly like daytime product, except thicker and more absorbent
  • Available in XS
Attends Extra Better $0.97
  • No leakage barriers
  • One strip of elastic around entire leg opening
Attends Super Plus Better $0.97
  • Extra leakage barriers
  • More absorbent than Extra
Prevail Extra 31 oz. Better $0.99
  • Largest range of sizes: Youth to 2XL
  • Narrows through crotch for closer fit
  • Single leg gathers with large leg openings
Prevail Super Plus 50 oz. Better $1.11
  • Single leg gathers
  • Larger leg openings accommodate larger thighs
  • Channel collection system
Tena Plus 19oz Best $0.96
  • Fully elasticized legs with narrow elastic across crotch for narrower fit
  • Double leg guards
Tena Extra 21 oz Best $1.12
  • Same as Plus, but with disposal tape
Nightingale Underwear Good $0.69
  • Most economical


*absorbency listed when provided by manufacturer
**cost each based on Large size/case

All of the breathable underwear:
  • Are white in color
  • Have a cloth-like outer layer
  • Have tear away sides
  • Are easy to pull up and down
Most of the products are available in Small, Medium, Large and X-Large sizes.